Why I’m boycotting some pagan blogs

Hi, I’m an INFJ on the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator, and I like labels.

It’s very simple when you’re a mainline Christian and can just name your denomination and have everybody recognize it. I was an Episcopalian, an Anglican. It had a lot of syllables, but nobody argued (much) about what it meant. (Argument came from other Episcopalians who didn’t want any openly gay clergy. I assume they had no problem with neurotic, closeted ones, of which the Episcopal Church used to have a large number.)

I celebrated Lughnasad, which for me involved actually worshipping Lugus and Rosmerta with prayers and offerings, including an oatmeal stout and some corn on the cob as a nod to the grain harvest the gods have provided. Not surprisingly (at least, I wasn’t surprised), I subsequently had a bout of “druid fever”, wanting once again to be a druid and train with an order and have a nice white robe and a nice clean label. Most neopagans, I daresay, have a pretty good idea of who druids are and what they do. Even if there’s a divide between druids who look mainly to the Druid Revival of the eighteenth century for inspiration and those who look to the ancient druids of Ireland, Britain, and Gaul, there’s still a lot of common ground there.

But I’m probably not going to join a druid order and train with it, or change my spiritual practice to conform to an ideal of druidry so that I can wear that white robe and that clear label. There’s actually quite a lot of overlap between what I do as a polytheist and what I believe a druid is and does; creative inspiration, poetry, and writing play a large role in both. But the only label that seems to stick to me effectively is that word polytheist.

It’s an awkward word. It has a lot of syllables, and people seem unclear on what it means. Merriam-Webster’s “belief in or worship of more than one god” is clear enough to me, but some people who call themselves polytheists define the gods in ways that preclude actual worship. I don’t think you can worship an archetype, a fictional character, a constellation of forces; at least, I know I can’t. I know a lot of people in fandom who have very intense relationships with fictional characters (and the actors who portray them), but it’s not worship, even if stories about those characters perform a meaning-bearing function in people’s lives akin to myth or scripture.

For me being a polytheist means primarily that I don’t define myself by what I believe or even what I do, so much as by what my relationships are. I’m a polytheist. I worship many gods. Well, which ones? At last count, Antinous, the Tetrad++, much of the Roman pantheon, and a number of Hellenic, Orphic, and Romano-Celtic deities. Plus some of my ancestors and some spirits. I don’t worship Captain America, I just have his shield on a t-shirt. (I do occasionally thank the gods for Chris Evans, however. Sometimes specifically for the films in which he appears semi-nude.)

The longer I practice polytheism, the less useful I find the writing of pagans who aren’t also in relationship with the gods, gods to whom they are devoted, gods whom they worship. I wouldn’t read a sex manual written by a life-long celibate, and I don’t see why I should take seriously any theologies by people who don’t believe in the theoi. It’s helpful that people put labels on their blogs; I know if someone calls themselves a humanist pagan or an atheopagan that they have nothing to say to me because I’m not their intended audience. Nor are they mine; I’m writing for people who, if not polytheists already, are at least open in mind and heart to the possibility that the gods are real and alive and that relationship with them is rational, worthwhile, and life-enriching.

Is it a boycott if you don’t shop where the merchant isn’t selling anything you need? Perhaps not, but it certainly makes for a catchy blog title.


Published by


Writer, musician, polytheist, and friend of birds. I like science fiction, fantasy, and superheroes a lot.

5 thoughts on “Why I’m boycotting some pagan blogs”

  1. Here I thought you were actually boycotting blogs and had produced a lengthy essay/article on your reasons why. Well, you fooled me! Anyway, yea, I totally get what you’re saying. I think it’s all about relevance and what you want to feed your brain. I mostly read blogs by witches, spirit-workers, etc. with some pagan and polytheist blogs throw into the mix.

    Also, Chris Evans, heh.


  2. There was some discussion of this–particularly one Ioannes Humanismus–at MGW. I support your decision fully, and will be writing about a few of these things in the near future as well…


    1. It’s not so much a decision as a realization that there are blogs I don’t read because they’re not actually written for me, and they don’t help me in cultivating my spirituality. I actually have never read I.H. regularly, for example. And I usually regret it when I do….


  3. I think that no one really knows if there is one god with many aspects or many gods governing individual aspects. I think that whatever the realm of the spirit is, those who used to be physical humans and are now in spirit form do respond to sincere attention from those of us still on this physical plane. Our task is to be sincere and to listen. Antinous was a human who is now a spirit. He can only speak to us as a spirit. Listening as an Anglican, a Druid, a Polytheist, a Catholic, a Jew, a Moslem, etc. is not as important as listening. The spirits are limited in how they can communicate with us physical beings. But as long as we listen, they are communicating all the time. In my opinion, they communicate through the events of our lives, the hunches we receive, the coincidences we encounter. I think the guide, they do not force or dictate. One god or many gods, each one of us is in full control over how we react to what life presents us. Yes, we are influenced by our life histories, but we always have control and therefore responsibility. My opinion is no more valid than anyone else’s – but I thought I would contribute to the discussion.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s